Systematics of pterobranchs from the Cambrian Period Burgess Shales of Canada and the early evolution of graptolites


Authors: Ramírez-Guerrero GM, Cameron CB

Published in: Bulletin of Geosciences, volume 96, issue 1; pages: 1 - 18; Received 3 May 2020; Accepted in revised form 25 August 2020; Online 16 November 2020

Keywords: graptolites, Hemichordata, middle Cambrian, Burgess Shale,

full text (PDF, 4.13 MB)

Export to RIS



Pterobranchs originated in the basal Cambrian (Fortunian) and are mostly known by their tubes preserved in the fossil record. The earliest forms are represented by bushy erect growing colonies that are not widely studied due to their scarcity, preservation quality and species misidentification. For this reason, early phylogenetic relationships within the group are not clearly established. Middle Cambrian Burgess Shale graptolites were poorly known, based on the presence of Chaunograptus scandens, some debatable species of the genus Yuknessia, and other undetermined fragmented material. This study represents a complete description of C. scandens, a consensus for Yuknessia simplex and Y. stephenensis, and new reports of Protohalecium hallianum and Mastigograptus sp. from the Burgess Shale localities, which have also been found in other Burgess Shale type localities in Utah and Australia. Phylogenetic analyses of 34 discrete morphological traits from these Burgess Shale genera and some known benthic and planktic taxa (n = 22), place these Cambrian species as basal forms closer to the pseudocolonial pterobranch Cephalodiscus and the living graptolite Rhabdopleura.


Andersson, K. 1907. Die Pterobranchier der schwedischen Sudpolar Expedition 1901-1903. Wissenchaft Ergebnisse Schwedische Studpolar-Expedition 5, 1-122.

Andres, D. 1961. Die Struktur von Mastigograptiden aus einem ordovizischen Geschiebe Berlins. Neues Jahrbuch für Geologie und Paläontologie 12, 636-647.

Babcock, L.E. & Zhang, W.T. 2001. Stratigraphy, paleontology, and depositional setting of the Chengjiang Lagerstätte (lower Cambrian), Yunnan, China, 66-86. In Peng, S.C., Babcock, L.E. & Zhu, M.Y. (eds) Cambrian of South China. University of Science and Technology of China Press, Hefei.

Bapst, D.W., Bullock, P.C., Melchin, M.J., Sheets, H.D. & Mitchell, C.E. 2012. Graptoloid diversity and disparity became decoupled during the Ordovician mass extinction. Proceedings of the Natural Academy of Sciences 109(9), 3428-3433. View article

Bates, D.E.B. & Urbanek, A. 2002. The ultrastructure, development, and systematic position of the graptolite genus Mastigograptus. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 47(3), 445-458.

Bateson, W. 1885. The later stages in the development of Balanoglossus kowalevskii, with a suggestion as to the affinities of the Enteropneusta. Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science 25, 81-122.

Bayer, F.M. 1962. A new species of Cephalodiscus (Hemichordata: Pterobranchia), the first record from the tropical Western Atlantic. Bulletin of Marine Science of the Gulf and Caribbeans 12, 306-312.

Beli, E., Aglieri, G., Strano, F., Maggioni, D., Telford, M.J., Piraino, S. & Cameron, C.B. 2018. The zoogeography of extant rhabdopleurid hemichordates (Pterobranchia?:?Graptolithina), with a new species from the Mediterranean Sea. Invertebrate Systematics 32(1), 100-110. View article

Bengtson, S. & Urbanek, A. 1986. Rhabdotubus, a Middle Cambrian rhabdopleurid hemichordate. Lethaia 19, 293-308. View article

Briggs, D.E.G., Erwin, D.H. & Collier, F.J. 1994. The fossils of the Burgess Shale. 238 pp. Smithsonian Institution Press, Washington & London.

Bronn, H.G. 1849. Handbuch der Geschichte der Natur. Dritter Band, Zweite Abtheilung. II. Theil: Organisches Leben (Schluß). Index palaeontologicus oder Ueberblick der bis jetzt bekannten fossilen Organismen. 1106 pp. Schweizerbart, Stuttgart. View article

Bulman, O.M.B. 1955. Part V: Graptolithina. In Moore, R.C. (ed.) Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. The Geological Society of America and the University of Kansas, US.

Bulman, O.M.B. 1970. Part V: Graptolithina with sections on Enteropneusta and Pterobranchia. Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. 163 pp. The Geological Society of America and the University of Kansas, US.

Cameron, C.B. 2018. Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Part V, Chapter 2, Class Enteropneusta: Introduction, Morphology, Life Habits, Systematic Descriptions, and Future Research. Treatise Online 109, 1-22.

Cameron, C.B., Garey, J. & Swalla, B. 2000. Evolution of the chordate body plan: New insights from phylogenetic analyses of deuterostome phyla. Proceedings of the Natural Academy of Science 97(9), 4469-4474. View article

Cannon, J.T., Swalla, B.J., & Halanych, K.M. 2013. Hemichordate molecular phylogeny reveals a novel cold-water clade of harrimaniid acorn worms. The Biological Bulletin 225, 194-204. View article

Caron, J.B. & Jackson, D.A. 2008. Paleoecology of the Greater Phyllopod Bed community, Burgess Shale. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 258, 222-256. View article

Caron, J.B., Gaines, R., Mangano, G., Streng, M. & Daley, A. 2010. A new Burgess Shale-type assemblage from the “thin” Stephen Formation of the Southern Canadian Rockies. Geology 38, 811-814. View article

Caron, J.B., Conway-Morris, S. & Cameron, C.B. 2013. Tubicolous enteropneusts from the Cambrian. Nature 7442, 503-506. View article

Chapman, F. & Thomas, D.E. 1936. The Cambrian hydroids of the Heathcote and Monegeeta districts. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Victoria 48, 193-212.

Chapman, A.J., Durman, P.N. & Rickards, R.B. 1996. A provisional classification of the graptolite Order Dendroidea. Paläontologische Zeitschrift 70, 189-202. View article

Conway-Morris, S. & Robison, R.A. 1988. More soft-bodied animals and algae from the Middle Cambrian of Utah and British Columbia. The University of Kansas Paleontological Contributions 122, 1-48.

Cooper, R.A., Rigby, S., Loydell, D.K. & Bates, D.E.B. 2012. Palaeoecology of the Graptoloidea. Earth-Science Reviews 112, 23-41. View article

Durman, P.N. & Sennikov, N.V. 1993. A new rhabdopleurid hemichordate from the Middle Cambrian of Siberia. Palaeontology 36, 283-296.

Emig, C.C. 1977. Sur une nouvelle espece de Cephalodiscus, C. (C.) caliciformis n. sp. (Hemichordata, Pterobranchia), récoltée a Madagascar. Bulletin du Museum National d’Histoire Naturelle 3e série 493, 1077-1082.

Erdtmann, B.D. 1982. A reorganization and proposed phylogenetic classification of planktic Tremadoc (early Ordovician) dendroid graptolites. Norsk Geologisk Tidsskrift 62(2), 121-145.

Goloboff, P.A., Farris, J. & Nixon, K.C. 2008. TNT, a free program for phylogenetic analysis. Cladistics 24, 774-786. View article

Gonzalez, P. & Cameron, C.B. 2012. Ultrastructure of the coenecium of Cephalodiscus (Pterobranchia, Hemichordata). Canadian Journal of Zoology 90, 1261-1269. View article

Guo, J., Li, Y. & Shu, D. 2010. Fossil macroscopic algae from the Yanjiahe Formation, Terreneuvian of the Three Gorges area, South China: Acta Palaeontologica Sinica 49, 336-342.

Hall, J. 1882. Descriptions of the species of fossils found in the Niagara Group at Waldron, Indiana. Indiana Department of Geology and Natural History, 11th Annual Report, 217-345.

Harmer, S.F. 1905. The Pterobranchia of the Siboga Expedition with an account of other species. Siboga Expedition Monograph 26, 1-133. View article

Harvey, T.H.P., Ortega-Hernández, J., Lin, J.P., Zhao, Y. & Butterfield, N.J. 2012. Burgess Shale-type microfossils from the middle Cambrian Kaili Formation, Guizhou Province, China. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 57(2), 423-436. View article

Hou, X.G., Bergström, J., Wang, H.F., Feng, X.H. & Chen, A.L. 1999. The Chengjiang Fauna: Exceptionally Well-Preserved Animals from 530 Million Years Ago. 170 pp. Yunnan Science and Technology Press, Kunming.

Hou, X.G., Aldridge, R.J., Siveter, D.J., Siveter, D.J., Williams, M., Zalasiewicz, J. & Ma, X.Y. 2011. An early Cambrian Hemichordate Zooid. Current Biology 21, 612-616. View article

Hu, S., Erdtmann, B.-D., Steiner, M., Zhang, Y., Zhao, F., Zhang, Z. & Han, J. 2018. Malongitubus: a possible pterobranch hemichordate from the early Cambrian of South China. Journal of Paleontology 92(1), 26-32. View article

Jefferies, R.P.S. 1986. The Ancestry of the Vertebrates. 376 pp. British Museum (Natural History) and Cambridge University Press, London.

John, C.C. 1931. Cephalodiscus. Discovery Reports 3, 223-260.

Johnson, J.H. 1966. A review of Cambrian algae. Quarterly of the Colorado School of Mines 61, 1-162.

Johnston, T.H. & Muirhead, N.G. 1951. Cephalodiscus. Reports BANZ Antarctic Research Expedition (B) 1, 91-120.

Johnston, K.J., Johnston, P.A. & Powell, W.G. 2009. A new, Middle Cambrian, Burgess Shale-type biota, Bolaspidella Zone, Chancellor Basin, southeastern British Columbia. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 277, 106-126. View article

Kirjanov, V. 1968. Paleontology and stratigraphy of the Baltic deposits in the Volhyn-Podolia. 5-27. In Karandievskiy, V., Ishenko, T. & Kirjanov, V. (eds) Paleontology and Stratigraphy of the Lower Paleozoic of Volhyn-Podolia. Naukova Dumka, Kiev.

Kozlowski, R. 1949. Les graptolithes et quelques nouveaux groupes d’animaux du Tremadoc de la Pologne. Palaeontologica Polonica 3, 1-330.

Kozlowski, R. 1966. On the structure and relationships of graptolites. Journal of Paleontology 40(3), 489-501.

Landing, E., Antcliffe, J.B., Geyer, G., Kouchinsky, A., Bowser, S.S. & Andreas, A. 2018. Early evolution of colonial animals (Ediacaran Evolutionary Radiation-Cambrian Evolutionary Radiation-Great Ordovician Biodiversification Interval). Earth-Science Reviews 178, 105-135. View article

Lankester, E.R. 1877. Notes on the embryology and classification of the animal kingdom; comprising a revision of speculations relative to the origin and significance of the germlayers. Quarterly Journal of Microscopical Science 17, 339-454.

Lankester, E.R. 1905. On a new species of Cephalodiscus (C. nigrescens) from the Antarctic ocean. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London 76, 400-402. View article

LoDuca, S.T. & Kramer, A. 2014. Graptolites form the Wheeler and Marjum Formations (Cambrian, Series 3) of Utah. Journal of Paleontology 88(2), 403-410. View article

LoDuca, S.T., Caron, J.B., Schiffbauer, J.D., Xiao, S., Kramer, A. 2015a. A reexamination of Yuknessia from the Cambrian of British Columbia and Utah. Journal of Paleontology 89(1), 82-95. View article

LoDuca, S.T. Wu, M., Zhao, Y., Xiao, S., Schiffbauer, J.D., Caron, J.B. & Babcock, L. 2015b. Reexamination of Yuknessia from the Cambrian of China and first report of Fuxianospira from North America. Journal of Paleontology 89(6), 899-911. View article

Maddison, W.P. & Maddison. D. 2018. Mesquite: a modular system for evolutionary analysis. Version 3.51.

Maletz, J. 2013. Hemichordata (Pterobranchia, Enteropneusta) and the fossil record. Palaeogeography, Paleoclimatology, Palaeoecology 398, 16-27. View article

Maletz, J. 2014a. Graptolite reconstructions and interpretations. Paläontologische Zeitschrift 89, 271-286. View article

Maletz, J. 2014b. The classification of the Pterobranchia (Cephalodiscida and Graptolithina). Bulletin of Geosciences 89(3), 477-540. View article

Maletz, J. 2017. Graptolite Paleobiology. 336 pp. Wiley-Blackwell, UK. View article

Maletz, J. 2019a. Tracing the evolutionary origins of the Hemichordata (Enteropneusta and Pterobranchia). Paleoworld 28, 58-72. View article

Maletz, J. 2019b. Dictyonema Hall and its importance for the evolutionary history of the Graptoloidea. Palaeontology 62(1), 151-161. View article

Maletz, J. & Beli, E. 2018. Part V, Second Revision, Chapter 15: Subclass Graptolithina and incertae sedis Family Rhabdopleuridae: Introduction and Systematic Descriptions. Treatise Online 101, 1-14. View article

Maletz, J. & Cameron, C.B. 2016. Part V, Chapter 3: Introduction to the class Pterobranchia Lankester, 1877. Treatise Online 82, 1-15. View article

Maletz, J. & Gonzalez, P. 2017. Part V, Chapter 14: Order Cephalosdiscida: Introduction and systematic descriptions. Treatise Online 100, 1-8. View article

Maletz, J. & Steiner, M. 2015. Graptolite (Hemichordata, Pterobranchia) preservation and identification in the Cambrian Series 3. Palaeontology 58(6), 1073-1107. View article

Maletz, J., Steiner, M. & Fatka, O. 2005. Middle Cambrian pterobranchs and the question: What is a graptolite? Lethaia 38, 73-85. View article

Maletz, J., Bates, D.E.B., Brussa, E.D., Cooper, R.A., Lenz, A.C., Riva, J.F., Toro, B.A. & Zhang, Y. 2014. Part V, Revision 2, Chapter 12: Glossary of the Hemichordata. Treatise Online 62, 1-23. View article

Maletz, J., Lenz, A.C. & Bates, D.E.B. 2016. Part V, Second Revision, Chapter 4: Morphology of the pterobranch tubarium. Treatise Online 76, 1-63. View article

Markham, J.C. 1971. The species of Cephalodiscus collected during operation Deep Freeze, 1956-1959. Antarctic Research Series 17, 83-110. View article

Mierzejewski, P. 1986. Ultrastructure, taxonomy and affinities of some Ordovician and Silurian organic microfossils. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 47, 129-220.

Mierzejewski, P. 1988. Encrusting graptolites from the Mulde Beds of Gotland. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 33(3), 261-266.

Mitchell, C.E., Melchin, M., Cameron, C.B. & Maletz, J. 2013. Phylogenetic analysis reveals that Rhabdopleura is an extant graptolite. Lethaia 46, 34-56. View article

Nanglu, K., Caron, J.B., Conway-Morris, S. & Cameron, C.B. 2016. Cambrian suspension-feeding tubicolous hemichordates. BMC Biology 14, art. 56. View article

Nicholson, H.A. 1872. A monograph of the British Graptolitidae. 133 pp. Blackwood & Sons, Edinburgh & London.

Obut, A.M. 1964. Order Hemichordata. In Orlov, Y.A. (ed.) Osnovy Palaeontologii. Nedra Press, Moscow.

Quilty, P.G. 1971. Cambrian and Ordovician dendroids and hydroids of Tasmania. Journal of the Geological Society of Australia 17(2), 171-189. View article

Rickards, R.B. 1993. Graptolithina, 537-542. In Benton, M.J. (ed.) The Fossil Record. Chapman & Hall, London.

Rickards, R.B. & Durman, P.N. 2006. Evolution of the earliest graptolites and other hemichordates, 5-92. In Bassett, M. & Deisler, V. (eds) Studies in Paleozoic paleontology. National Museum of Wales Geological Series No. 25, Cardiff.

Ridewood, W.G. 1920. A key for the ready identification of the species of Cephalodiscus. Annals and Magazine of Natural History, London 5 Series 9, 407-410. View article

Romer, A.S. 1967. Major steps in vertebrate evolution. Science 158, 1629-1637. View article

Ruedemann, R. 1908. Graptolites of New York. Part II: Graptolites of the Higher Beds. New York State Museum Memoir 11, 1-583.

Ruedemann, R. 1931. Some new Middle Cambrian Fossils from British Columbia. Proceedings of the United States National Museum 79(2893), 1-18. View article

Ruedemann, R. 1947. Graptolites of North America. Geological Society of America Memoir 19, 1-652. View article

Simakov, O., Kawashima, T., Marlétaz, F., Jenkins, J., Koyanagi, R., Mitros, T., Hisata, K., Bredeson, J., Shoguchi, E., Gyoja, F., Yue, J.-X., Chen,Y.-C., Freeman, R., Sasaki, A., Hikosaka-Katayama, T., Sato, A., Fujie, M., Baughman, K., Levine, J., Gonzalez, P., Cameron, C., Fritzenwanker, J., Pani, A., Goto, H., Kanda, M., Arakaki, N., Yamasaki, S., Qu, J., Cree, A., Ding, Y., Dinh, H., Dugan, S., Holder, M., Jhangiani, S., Kovar, C., Lee, S., Lewis, L., Morton, D., Nazareth, L., Okwuonu, G., Santibanez, J., Chen, R., Richards, S., Muzny, D., Gillis, A., Peshkin, L., Wu, M., Humphreys, T., Su, Y.-H., Putnam, N., Schmutz, J., Fujiyama, A., Yu, Jr.-K., Tagawa, K., Worley, K., Gibbs, R., Kirschner, M., Lowe, C., Satoh, N., Rokhsar, D. & Gerhart, J. 2015. Hemichordate genomes and deuterostome origins. Nature 527, 459-465. View article

Skinner, E.S. 2005. Taphonomy and depositional circumstances of exceptionally preserved fossils from the Kinzers Formation (Cambrian), Southeastern Pennsylvania. Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology 220, 167-192. View article

Slater, B.J., Harvey, T.H.P. & Butterfield, N.J. 2018a. Small carbonaceous fossils (SCFs) from the Terreneuvian (Lower Cambrian) of Baltica. Paleontology 61(3), 417-439. View article

Slater, B.J., Willman, S., Budd, G.E. & Peel, J.S. 2018b. Widespread preservation of small carbonaceous fossils (SCFs) in the early Cambrian of North Greenland. Geology 46(2), 107-110. View article

Steiner, M. & Maletz, J. 2012. Cambrian graptolites (Pterobranchia) and the origin of colonial organization in metazoans. Centenary Meeting of the Paläontologische Gesellschaft. Programme, Abstracts and Field Guides, p. 174.

Swofford, D.L. 2002. PAUP: Phylogenetic Analysis Using Parsimony (and Other Methods), Version 4.0 Beta 10. Sinauer Associates, Sunderland.

Thomas, D.E. & Henderson, Q.J. 1945. Some fossils from the Dundas Series, Dundas. Papers and Proceedings of the Royal Society of Tasmania 1944, 1-8.

Urbanek, A. 1983. The significance of graptoblasts in the life cycle of crustoid graptolites. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 28(3-4), 313-326.

Urbanek, A. 1986. The enigma of graptolite ancestry: lesson from a phylogenetic debate, 184-226. In Hoffman, A. & Nitecki, M. (eds) Problematic Fossil Taxa (Oxford Monographs on Geology and Geophysics N°5). Oxford University Press and Clarendon Press, Oxford.

Urbanek, A. & Mierzejewski, P. 1984. The ultrastructure of the Crustoidea and the evolution of graptolite skeletal tissues. Lethaia 17, 73-91. View article

Urbanek, A. & Towe, K.M. 1974. Ultrastructural studies on Graptolites 1. The Periderm and its derivatives in the Dendroidea and in Mastigograptus. Smithsonian contributions to Paleobiology 20, 1-49. View article

Walcott, C.D. 1879. The Utica Slate and related formations of the same geological horizon. Transactions of the Albany Institute 10, 1-17.

Walcott, C.D. 1919. Cambrian Geology and Paleontology IV. Middle Cambrian Algae. Smithsonian Miscellaneous Collections 67(2542), 217-260.

Zhao, F., Caron, J.B., Bottjer, D.J., Hu, S., Yin, Z. & Zhu, M. 2013. Diversity and species abundance patterns of the early Cambrian (Series 2, Stage 3) Chengjiang Biota from China. Paleobiology 40, 50-69. View article

Zhao, Y., Zhu, M.Y., Babcock, L.E. & Peng, J. 2011. The Kaili Biota: Marine Organisms from 508 Million Years Ago. 251 pp. Guizhou University Press, Guiyang.